American Idol for Dummies, Well jennifer you arent a dummy, I LOVE YOU!!!

Barry Manilow is the star how helped the idols this week

Mendisa sung: I don’t hurt anymore by Diana Washington
Comments
Me- Well the beginning was great but she couldn’t hit the high notes at the end
Paula- Performance was flawless
Randy- Classy great way to start the night, good singing
Simon- He think she is blossoming, loved the song, very sexy performance, a great stripper song?!?!?!?

Bucky sung: Oh boy by Buddy Holly
Comments
Me- Kind of dry, not really exciting, he messed up at the end of the song, like skipped a word and realized it.
Paula-had fun on stage and a good song performance
Randy- Prefect song for Bucky, not a god ending note.
Simon- Really Check, It was nothing more then a karaoke performance, a “so what” performance.

Paris sung: Fever by Peggy Lee
Comments
Me-Looks very comfortable on stage, kick ass song for her, I think she rocked the house.
Paula- Vocal were impeccable
Randy-Thought wasn’t going to be a good song. But she rocked it out, blew it out the box
Simon- Perfect voice for the song.

Chris sung: Walk the line by Johnny Cash
Comments
Me-Kind of a bland song, but it picked up at the end, and he is a little out of tone with the song in the end.
Paula-You grow and grow each week, ready for the final four.
Randy-Not the best vocal, but put your own spin on the song.
Simon- not the best vocal, but it doesn’t matter, you made it your own version. Hated Bucky’s version of Oh Boy.

Kathren sung: Come Rain or Come Shine by Ella Fitzgerald
Comments
Me- A little flat in the beginning. A little off throughout the song. Dress she is wearing is too big for her body.
Paula- Thought it was a great performance
Randy- Not his favorite vocal performance, but good way to work out the song.
Simon- Tonight you turned into a star. It was watching a real seasoned performer.

Taylor sung: Not Fade Away by Buddy Holly
Comments
Me- Kind of basic, but he started to dance and it was cool.
Paula- Making an exercise video out of his dancing, one of a kind.
Randy- Having a blast with the song, the song wasn’t challenging.
Simon- It was a complete mess, hideous party moment.

Lisa sung: Why do fools fall in love? By Frankie Lymon
Comments
Me-She rocked the house
Paula- very week a better performance
Randy- Give her props, she can blow
Simon- He thought she will make it to the final four.

Elliot sung: Teach me tonight al jero?
Comments
Me- I thought he was great.
Paula- A fantastic breath of air, you are great
Randy- You worked out the song, a couple of ruff spot but it was a difficult song but he rocked it.
Simon- Your singing was fantastic, I loved it.

Kevin sung: When I fall in love Nat King Cole
Comments
Me-I think he did well, he sung it softly.
Paula- Another great job.
Randy- Did a good job with the song, a little pitchy.
Simon- I like you, wasn’t the best version, but you know who your audience is.

Kelly sung: walking after midnight by Patsy Cline
Comments
Me-. She is fuckin awesome, great choice of a song.
Paula- a True Kelly pickler performance.
Randy- Great song choice
Simon- I was ballsy and sexy, it was great.


Ace sung: In the Still on the Night by Five Satins
Comments
Me- I think he was a good ending to the show.
Paula- The sexiest performance all season